Research Design

Content

Games

Four games run through the course. You play first; the discussion afterwards is where the learning happens, and the learning log entry at the end of the class is where you write down what it means for your project.

AI scenario sort

In Class 1 (Tue 2 Feb) you sort six cards, each describing a way a student might use AI in their research, into three piles: appropriate (supports my learning), depends (context decides) and inappropriate (replaces my learning). You sort in groups of three or four.

  1. Place (5 minutes). Sort the six cards together as a group.
  2. Argue (15 minutes). Compare your piles with the other groups and argue the cards you split on.
  3. Extract (7 minutes). Name four or five principles behind your choices.
  4. Record (3 minutes). Photograph the piles and the principles.

Your principles become the course’s AI policy. Learning log entry 1 follows at the end of the class.

Ethics card game

In Class 7 (Tue 23 Feb) you play in groups of three or four. Each dilemma card describes a situation from speech technology research with two options, A and B. Every option costs something, and the game makes you say what.

How to play (one rules sheet per group)

  1. Each player holds the eight value cards. Shuffle the dilemma cards and put them face down.
  2. The reader turns over a dilemma and reads it aloud, with both options.
  3. Everyone decides A or B, and puts face down the one value card that decided it for them.
  4. Reveal together. Anyone who chose differently, or played a different value, explains first (3 minutes).
  5. Agree a decision, or record the split. Write down the value that lost.
  6. Pass the reader role to the left. About five minutes per dilemma.

There is no right answer on any card. What matters is which value you were willing to give up, and why.

The eight value cards

Value What it stands for
Privacy Keep people from being identified or exposed
Fairness Every group is served equally well
Consent People agree, knowing what they agree to
Scientific quality The result is valid and generalises
Feasibility It can be done in the time and budget
Openness Others can check, reuse and build on it
Benefit The people affected gain from it
Your career Publishing, funding, finishing on time

The dilemma cards are handed out in class. In the second half of the class you write a dilemma card from your own project and play it with someone from another group.

Learning log entry 2 follows at the end of the class.

LEGO reproducibility challenge

In Class 11 (Fri 12 Mar) you work in pairs, each pair with an identical LEGO kit. The game shows how much a description leaves out, even when its author thinks it’s complete.

Build, document, swap, rebuild

  1. Build and document (10 minutes). Build something from 15-25 pieces of your kit. Write instructions so another pair could rebuild it. Words and sketches only, no photos. Hide your original under the table while the other pair rebuilds.
  2. Rebuild (10 minutes). Pass your instructions (not the model) to the next pair; the last pair passes to the first. Rebuild theirs. No questions allowed; note every guess you make.
  3. Compare (10 minutes). Put original and copy side by side. Where did they differ, and which missing detail caused it?

From bricks to your methods section

The challenge is adapted from the LEGO® Metadata for Reproducibility game pack by Mary Donaldson and Matt Mahon (University of Glasgow, 2019, https://doi.org/10.36399/gla.pubs.196477), licensed CC BY 4.0. LEGO® is a trademark of the LEGO Group, which does not sponsor or endorse this course.

Learning log entry 4 follows at the end of the class.

Research Futures

Research Futures runs during the poster session in Class 13 (Fri 19 Mar). Every student and guest gets five Research Futures grant notes and invests them in the projects they would fund.

Rules

Each note has two lines to fill in: “Invested in (poster by):” and “Because:”.

Learning log entry 5 follows once the results are in.