Learning log
Weight: 10% (five entries, 2 points each)
Format: handwritten, in the notebook you get in Class 1
Entries: Class 1 (Tue 2 Feb), Class 7 (Tue 23 Feb), DuST (Mon 1 Mar), Class 11 (Fri 12 Mar), Class 13 (Fri 19 Mar)
Submit: a photo of each entry in BrightSpace before you leave the room; the DuST entry by Wednesday 3 March, 23:59
Purpose
Each game in this course gives you an experience. The log is where that experience becomes something you can use: you write down what happened, work out what it showed you, and decide what changes in your own project. Kolb (1984) describes learning from experience as a cycle of four steps: an experience, reflection on it, a new idea, and trying the idea out. Games are good at the first step. The log covers the other three.
Every entry ends with a specific change to your RQ or proposal, so the log feeds straight into the work that’s graded.
Why by hand
Writing by hand is slower, so you have to choose what’s worth writing down. It’s also the one piece of writing in this course where AI isn’t in the room. What’s on the page is your own thinking at that moment.
You may have read that handwriting beats typing for memory. The best-known study behind that claim (Mueller & Oppenheimer, 2014) wasn’t confirmed by a larger direct replication (Urry et al., 2021), so it isn’t our reason. What does have support is the kind of prompt: writing helps learning most when the prompts ask you to think about your own thinking (Bangert-Drowns et al., 2004). The prompts below are built that way.
How it works
- The last minutes of Classes 1, 7, 11 and 13 are set aside for the log. At DuST you take notes on the day and finish the entry at home.
- Half a page to a page per entry is plenty. The DuST entry can run to two pages.
- Write in English. Handwriting, spelling and grammar aren’t graded.
- Before you leave the room, photograph the entry and upload it to BrightSpace. Keep the notebook: you reread it in Class 13, and it helps w/ the revision note in your proposal.
- If you miss a class with a log entry, do the make-up for that game (see below) and upload the entry within a week.
- I’m the only one who reads your entries.
Prompts
Every entry answers the same four questions. Each entry adds one or two of its own.
- What happened? Two or three sentences, facts only.
- What surprised you, or where did you see it differently from others?
- What does that mean for your project?
- What will you change? Name the proposal section or the decision.
Entry 1 · Class 1, Tue 2 Feb · after the AI scenario sort (6 minutes)
- Which principle we named today will be hardest for you to keep, and why? Copy your answer onto a sticky note for the board.
- Which problem or curiosity from today would you spend six months on?
You don’t have a proposal yet, so for question 4 name what you’ll try first in the RQ workshop in Class 2.
Entry 2 · Class 7, Tue 23 Feb · after the ethics card game (7 minutes)
- Which value did you give up most easily? Would you give it up in your own project?
- Which harm from today’s opening could happen in your project?
Entry 3 · DuST, Mon 1 Mar · field notes (due Wed 3 Mar, 23:59)
On the day:
- Attend at least three talks or posters.
- For two of them, note the question, the data, the method, and one design choice you’d question.
- Talk to one researcher or developer: how did they choose their method, and what would they do differently?
At home, answer the four questions. End w/ what DuST changes in your project.
Entry 4 · Class 11, Fri 12 Mar · after the LEGO challenge (7 minutes)
- What did you leave out of your instructions because it seemed obvious?
- Which detail of your own study is like that, and where in your methods section does it go?
Entry 5 · Class 13, Fri 19 Mar · after the poster session and Research Futures (8 minutes)
- Reread entry 1 first. What has changed in what you want to study, and what changed it?
- Which question at your poster couldn’t you answer?
For question 4, name one change you’ll make to the proposal before you submit it.
Missed a class?
Do a short version of that game at home, then write the entry by hand in your notebook and upload it within a week of the class. The materials are in BrightSpace.
- Class 1: sort the six scenario cards (A-F) on your own into appropriate, depends and inappropriate, then compare your sort w/ the photo of the class board. Write about where you disagreed with the room.
- Class 7: take three dilemma cards. For each, choose A or B and the value you’d play, then compare w/ the groups’ record sheets. Write about a dilemma where your value would have lost.
- Class 11: document a small build (bricks, a paper fold, or a ten-step drawing) in words and sketches only. Give the instructions to someone outside the course and watch them rebuild it without asking questions. Write about where the rebuild first went wrong.
- Class 13: read three classmates’ poster PDFs and invest five €20,000 notes, one reason per note. Write about the reason you found hardest to write. Upload by Sunday 21 March.
- DuST: tell me beforehand and I’ll set an alternative task.
Make-ups are graded the same way as entries written in class.
Grading
The log is graded for completion. Each entry is worth 2 points:
- 2 points: answers the prompts and names a specific change. A specific change says where and what, e.g. “add speaker age to the sampling plan in section 5”.
- 1 point: written, but thin, or the change is vague (“improve my methods”).
- 0 points: missing.
Your total out of 10 is your learning log grade, worth 10% of the course grade.
Sources
Bangert-Drowns, R. L., Hurley, M. M., & Wilkinson, B. (2004). The effects of school-based writing-to-learn interventions on academic achievement: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 74(1), 29-58.
Kolb, D. A. (1984). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development. Prentice Hall.
Mueller, P. A., & Oppenheimer, D. M. (2014). The pen is mightier than the keyboard: Advantages of longhand over laptop note taking. Psychological Science, 25(6), 1159-1168.
Urry, H. L., et al. (2021). Don’t ditch the laptop just yet: A direct replication of Mueller and Oppenheimer’s (2014) study 1 plus mini meta-analyses across similar studies. Psychological Science, 32(3), 326-339.